Well, were do we begin? I recently was made aware of this matter. I was denied the manual for the speed measuring device used against me. I thought that the onus of disclosure was on the prosecutor. The prosecutor says it's third party material. Prosecutor then lets the officer make statement that he tested and used the device according the specifications of the manufacture's manual. Can this be objected for the fact that I was not made aware of the manual and did not receive full disclosure?
Region of York v. McGuigan is this unconstitutional?
Re: Region of York v. McGuigan is this unconstitutional?
Did you object at the time ?
Re: Region of York v. McGuigan is this unconstitutional?
Sorry, to get back to you so late, I was out of the province for work. No, I didn't object. My question is, if the prosecutor is using the information and evidence of the officer, then don't we have a right to the same information? This new precedence that was set is saying the manual is third party. The Charter for disclosure says the onus of disclosure is on the prosecutor. The manual is not privileged information, it is public information. The manual is not out of their control, the prosecutor admits to having a copy in their office. Finally, the manual is relevant information, all officers admit to testing and using the speed measuring device according to the specifications of the manual. So how can this be third party information?
- FyreStorm
- Sr. Member

- Posts: 274
- Joined: Thu Mar 18, 2010 9:39 am
- Location: The Valley
-
Posting Awards
Re: Region of York v. McGuigan is this unconstitutional?
You don't have the right to the manual, paralegals have been trying forever to get it.
Re: Region of York v. McGuigan is this unconstitutional?
If a full copy is available at the office of the prosecutor. You can schedule an appointment to review it and take notes.
It really depends on which court house you get. Some e-mail you a PDF of the entire manual.
Most will give you the relevant pages for the testing, which the officer will provide evidence for.
Similar Topics
-
-
-
- Address for a Disclosure Request in York Region
- Posted in Courts and Procedure
- By leprechaun on
- Replies: 3
-
-
-
-
Speeding 145KM/h - 45KM over in a 100KM zone - York Region
- Posted in Exceeding the speed limit by 30 to 49 km/h
- By August2018 on
- Replies: 9
-
-
-
-
-
- Vicarious liability is unconstitutional
- Posted in General Talk
- By lawmen on
-
-
-
- Second judge... 172 Unconstitutional
- Posted in Stunt Driving
- By Bookm on
- Replies: 15
-
-
-
- Are stunt driving penalties unconstitutional?
- Posted in Stunt Driving
- By AlwaysAsking on
- Replies: 5
-
-
-
- Sneaky Speed trap in Niagra Region
- Posted in General Talk
- By BelSlySTi on
- Replies: 1
-
-
-
- Good paralegal in Niagara Region?
- Posted in General Talk
- By diehardfan on
- Replies: 3
-
-
-
- Disclosure in Durham Region
- Posted in Careless Driving
- By Richmondhiller on
-
-
-
- 120km/h on 100km/h @HWY 401 - Chatham Region
- Posted in Exceeding the speed limit by 16 to 29 km/h
- By alef007 on
- Replies: 7
-
-
-
- charged driving 129 kph in an 80 zone durham region
- Posted in Exceeding the speed limit by 30 to 49 km/h
- By djohn780 on
- Replies: 2
-
-
-
- Highway 17, Ontario - Kenora Region 120 in a 90
- Posted in Exceeding the speed limit by 30 to 49 km/h
- By skiergolfer75 on
- Replies: 2
-
-
-
- York Regions Prosecutors Office fax#
- Posted in General Talk
- By Occidio on
- Replies: 5
-
-
-
- 5 miles over speeding ticket in New York state for Ontario r
- Posted in Traffic Offences Outside Ontario
- By merimarzi on
- Replies: 1
-
-
-
- Speed trap: SB Royal York, N of the Queensway, Toronto
- Posted in Speed Traps
- By FiReSTaRT on
- Replies: 4
-
-
-
- Improper right turn (York & Front St)
- Posted in Improper right turn
- By vancouver1974 on
- Replies: 3
-
-
-
-
- New York State...
- Posted in Traffic Offences Outside Ontario
- By erinhugh on
- Replies: 8
-
-
-
- New York to Ontario Abstract
- Posted in General Talk
- By GaryChatham on
- Replies: 2
-
Featured Topics
lift laws, bumper height laws, headlight height laws
hey all im lifting my 03 f350 crew cab..
and ive called 3 different local police stations with NO HELP AT ALL...
im wondering...
is there bumper height laws?
headlight height laws?
what is a headlight?? ( like can i put any light at the proper level and it be legal?? or does it have to be a certain…
Falsely Accused of Handheld Device Usage
Hi!
This is my first time ever getting a ticket and I am completely frustrated and don't know what to do.
On July 7th, I was driving to work, taking my usual route and it's about a 15 minute drive for me. At the first red light, I noticed I had a bit of time thanks to the countdown so I quickly…
Radar Gun Error Code & Incomplete Disclosure
Hello,
I'm hoping somebody can point me in the right direction to track down various radar gun error codes.
Way back in March of this year I was stopped for speeding, 86kmh in a 60 Community Safety Zone, on Mayfield Rd., on the outskirts of Brampton. (Aloa school)
The cop was using hand held radar,…
Fail to Stop for School Bus- Owner - 175 (20)
Hi everyone,
My husband was driving my car and passed a school bus with flashing lights. He did not realize this until he was past the bus. The driver honked at him but there were no cops nearby and he didn't get pulled over. I believe the driver or witnesses reported this and we got issued a…
Prohibited Turn Sign Cannot be Seen
Hey guys I was hoping for some advice on my first ever ticket.
I just moved to the Aurora area and made a prohibited left turn between the prohibited hours. This is my very first ticket so I am unsure as to how to precede. I have already requested and received my court date and I assume the next…
Novice Driver B.A.C Above 0%
heres the story
i am 25 with a G2 Drivers license. had a lot to drink saturday night. woke up the next morning and drove home around 1pm sunday. got pulled over for speeding, police officer smelled booze had me blow a breathalyzer. i blew 0.035 . he aloud my passenger to drive my truck home. he gave…
Red Light Camera has extended delay for ticket
Hello Folks,
Well please confirm a couple of things.
1> Red Light Camera ticket is a "parking ticket" in essence, does not go on the record, so could just pay and forget.
2> Can early resolution, bring down the ticket fine, only reason would be excellent driving record, last 10 years. If…
Improper Left Turn: Harbor & Yonge St
Hi, last summer I was pulled over when I made a left turn from he middle lane at Harbor and Yonge Street (heading east on the Gardiner and taking the Yonge exit). I swear they nabbed about 10 people in 5 minutes. Anyways, I decided to challenge in court, my court date is in April and I have just…
How To Fight A No Seatbelt Ticket
The key ruling on fighting a seatbelt ticket is R. v. Kanda, 2008 and an example of it's application is R. v. Gupta, 2008.
In Kanda, the court established that this offence is a strict liability charge. In other words, you can offer a defence of due diligence. In Kanda the defendant explained the…
Have trial next week for Failure to Obey Stop Sign
Last July I got pulled over for failure to obey stop sign at a T-intersection in my neighbourhood. After I got my trial date I requested disclosure in November. Sent in another request for disclosure in early January and in mid-January got a call to pick it up at the court office. The disclosure…