Continued from http://www.ontariohighwaytrafficact.com/topic976.html As I understand it, "indication" covers all traffic control signals, arrow or not. "Circular green indication" is the full green signal, "green arrow indication" is the green arrow. Now, I couldn't follow why you referred to that distinction, so I'm not sure what this changes in your argument. It's late at night...I'll come back to it tomorrow. :wink:
Hey Bear, a question for you: say you come to a collision where a driver turning left has turned wide and collided with a car that turned right while "facing" (still up for debate here) a green arrow and a circular red. Would it be 'improper left turn' for the left turner, 'green arrow - fail to proceed as directed' for the right turner, or both? Or would it be 'red light - proceed before green' for the right turner? Oh, and in this case both drivers would have had their own respective lanes to turn into had the left turner not turned wide.
Hey Bear, a question for you: say you come to a collision where a driver turning left has turned wide and collided with a car that turned right while "facing" (still up for debate here) a green arrow and a circular red. Would it be 'improper left turn' for the left turner, 'green arrow - fail to proceed as directed' for the right turner, or both? Or would it be 'red light - proceed before green' for the right turner?
Oh, and in this case both drivers would have had their own respective lanes to turn into had the left turner not turned wide.
Therein lies the problem. Too much obscure wording. S. 144 should be re-worded. Also should be much more severe penalties for turning into the wrong lane at an intersection and disobeying yield sign. Maybe that could be tacked onto your e-mail regarding s. 154. Would ideally also like to see huge penalties for motorists who accelerate when they are being overtaken.
Squishy wrote:
If "their respective lane" is taken completely literally, then wouldn't that make the centre lanes of a six-lane street basically uncontrolled?
Therein lies the problem. Too much obscure wording.
S. 144 should be re-worded. Also should be much more severe penalties for turning into the wrong lane at an intersection and disobeying yield sign. Maybe that could be tacked onto your e-mail regarding s. 154. Would ideally also like to see huge penalties for motorists who accelerate when they are being overtaken.
Can't ask for too much, man. Might as well just run for office, then. ;) How about you tackle 144 and I'll tackle 154? We'll finally get some lane discipline and yield signs can make a comeback! (And who wants to ask for more roundabouts?) People who accelerate when others are passing them do technically fall under 172. I haven't heard of any such charges, though. I imagine such an incident would make the newspaper.
Can't ask for too much, man. Might as well just run for office, then.
How about you tackle 144 and I'll tackle 154? We'll finally get some lane discipline and yield signs can make a comeback! (And who wants to ask for more roundabouts?)
People who accelerate when others are passing them do technically fall under 172. I haven't heard of any such charges, though. I imagine such an incident would make the newspaper.
I do. They save hours. Except 90% of folks will have to have a 2 hour class to drill the roundabout etiquette into their brains. I haven't heard of any either. I can imagine the P/O driver though: "I was being overtaken, sped up by 10 km/hr, and the officer gave me a 7-point ticket! What will THAT do to MY insurance??? I didn't even know this was illegal let alone this bad!"
Squishy wrote:
And who wants to ask for more roundabouts?
I do. They save hours. Except 90% of folks will have to have a 2 hour class to drill the roundabout etiquette into their brains.
Squishy wrote:
People who accelerate when others are passing them do technically fall under 172. I haven't heard of any such charges, though. I imagine such an incident would make the newspaper.
I haven't heard of any either. I can imagine the P/O driver though: "I was being overtaken, sped up by 10 km/hr, and the officer gave me a 7-point ticket! What will THAT do to MY insurance??? I didn't even know this was illegal let alone this bad!"
"The more laws, the less justice" - Marcus Tullius Cicero
"The hardest thing to explain is the obvious"
Ignorance is a poor excuse. :P I imagine just a warning of the potential charges and insurance implications would be enough to scare most of them straight. Is there a tracking system for warnings given out, or can drivers talk their way into a warning indefinitely?
racer wrote:
I haven't heard of any either. I can imagine the P/O driver though: "I was being overtaken, sped up by 10 km/hr, and the officer gave me a 7-point ticket! What will THAT do to MY insurance??? I didn't even know this was illegal let alone this bad!"
Ignorance is a poor excuse.
I imagine just a warning of the potential charges and insurance implications would be enough to scare most of them straight. Is there a tracking system for warnings given out, or can drivers talk their way into a warning indefinitely?
Also they've been shown to reduce the severity of collisions and improve overall capacity versus traffic lights. I think they'd work in a lot of places, but, unfortunately, I think you're right about the etiquette here. Put them in Scarborough and half of the drivers going westbound who want to go south, instead of going to the right with everyone else, would turn left against the traffic flow. The rest of the GTA wouldn't yield properly entering/departing the roundabout and they'd try to run down pedestrians. If they missed their turn because they were talking on the cellphone, they'd stop and back up, or attempt a 3-point turn and drive against the traffic flow... probably turn the whole thing into a 24/7 Gong Show. :shock:
racer wrote:
I do. They save hours. Except 90% of folks will have to have a 2 hour class to drill the roundabout etiquette into their brains.
Also they've been shown to reduce the severity of collisions and improve overall capacity versus traffic lights. I think they'd work in a lot of places, but, unfortunately, I think you're right about the etiquette here. Put them in Scarborough and half of the drivers going westbound who want to go south, instead of going to the right with everyone else, would turn left against the traffic flow. The rest of the GTA wouldn't yield properly entering/departing the roundabout and they'd try to run down pedestrians. If they missed their turn because they were talking on the cellphone, they'd stop and back up, or attempt a 3-point turn and drive against the traffic flow... probably turn the whole thing into a 24/7 Gong Show.
I have a pretty general question, I am just wondering, If a Police Officer is doing radar (or laser.. whatever) on an unlit area of a highway and is out of his vehicle do this, with his vehicle faced into traffic (but on the center median emergency turn around). If there is multiple cars on the…
Hi there, this incident occurred on the night of July 1st, so my deadline on this ticket is July 16th. I plan on going to the court office on Monday so I figured I'd see what the experts think about my case. As a result, I apologize for the long post, but I don't want to leave out any details.
I have several problems and I'm wondering what my options are. This past weekend I was driving home from Lake Huron and was caught going 112 in an 80km/h zone. I am currently on my Quebec probationary license which is revoked at 4 demerit points. The penalty in Quebec for going +32 km/h over is 3…
Careless driving (HTA 131) deal down: lessons I learned
Careless Driving (6 demerit points) seems to be a "favourite" charge among police officers. It is certainly serious enough to get your attention and any plead down to say 2 or 3 points seems a gift. Here is a case where quick action and…
Hi All, I want some helpful tips in fighting this ticket. Here is what happened. Southbound approaching an intersection..my daughter in the left hand lane (4 lane street - Bathurst southbound Richmond Hill), she is riding behind a slower vehicle in the left hand lane. As she approaches the…
Does anybody know how you can check the status of your Demerit Points and how many you have collected over the last two years?
I just received a ticket as I was travelling through Barrie and am debating whether or not to fight it. My decision will be based on whether or not an infraction I received…
iam from ottawa, ont .... on the july 30( civic holiday weekend) i was drving my mom, dad, little sister to toronto to visit my sista....going throught belleville . i was driving on the right lane on the highway by the way ... suddenlly i saw cars in front of…
I was charged with careless driving last night. I am hoping anyone here can give me advice . Right now I am upset, angry, stiff and sore and don't know if I should just go right into my long drawn out account of what happened or just give a basic outline and answer questions anyone may have. I…