Hello, My elderly mother received a city bylaw ticket (Ottawa) for parking on private property. A tow trunk was at the scene to tow the vehicle, and they charged a "drop fee" to unhook the vehicle right away. The bylaw officer who issued the ticket was present and said that the ticket would get dismissed in court (as it was issued in error), and that there should be a way to apply to get the tow fee reimbursed once the ticket gets dismissed. The ticket has since been dismissed in court. I called the city on her behalf to inquire regarding reimbursement of the tow charge, and the clerk said it has to go through small claims court (which would cost more than the cost of the tow fee). Can anyone confirm if this is true? I would have thought the city would have an internal process to deal with these things. I appreciate anyone's help/insight. Thanks, Mike.
Hello,
My elderly mother received a city bylaw ticket (Ottawa) for parking on private property. A tow trunk was at the scene to tow the vehicle, and they charged a "drop fee" to unhook the vehicle right away. The bylaw officer who issued the ticket was present and said that the ticket would get dismissed in court (as it was issued in error), and that there should be a way to apply to get the tow fee reimbursed once the ticket gets dismissed.
The ticket has since been dismissed in court. I called the city on her behalf to inquire regarding reimbursement of the tow charge, and the clerk said it has to go through small claims court (which would cost more than the cost of the tow fee).
Can anyone confirm if this is true? I would have thought the city would have an internal process to deal with these things.
Unfortunately, small claims court is the only way to obtain recovery. You would have to sue both the City and the tow company. You'd also have to subpoena the by-law officer (who made the comments that it was an error) and the tow truck driver (as a witness) (and pay each a $6 witness fee!) to establish your case. So, in addition to paying your $75 filing fee, plus the $100 (trial setting fee), you'd already be out of pocket $187, not even factoring your time, expenses, photocopying and/or process serving fees (if you didn't serve individuals yourself). I don't know if you are prepared to pursue the matter given those expenses and aggravations, however, it IS likely that the city would settle the matter if you can properly establish your case. If so, you'd get your costs/expenses back, but not your time. Keep in mind though that if you ARE going to sue, you MUST put the city on notice within 10 days of the event causing the loss. That's a requirement under the Municipal Act. So, if more than 10 days have gone by, your opportunity to sue may have already been lost. If you're within the time frame, then put the city on notice right away and see if you can negotiate a resolution without having to sue.
Unfortunately, small claims court is the only way to obtain recovery. You would have to sue both the City and the tow company. You'd also have to subpoena the by-law officer (who made the comments that it was an error) and the tow truck driver (as a witness) (and pay each a $6 witness fee!) to establish your case. So, in addition to paying your $75 filing fee, plus the $100 (trial setting fee), you'd already be out of pocket $187, not even factoring your time, expenses, photocopying and/or process serving fees (if you didn't serve individuals yourself).
I don't know if you are prepared to pursue the matter given those expenses and aggravations, however, it IS likely that the city would settle the matter if you can properly establish your case. If so, you'd get your costs/expenses back, but not your time.
Keep in mind though that if you ARE going to sue, you MUST put the city on notice within 10 days of the event causing the loss. That's a requirement under the Municipal Act. So, if more than 10 days have gone by, your opportunity to sue may have already been lost. If you're within the time frame, then put the city on notice right away and see if you can negotiate a resolution without having to sue.
That's ridiculous. I get that the tow truck company will want to be paid for the work, but it should be billed directly to the city since it was their error. Was it an actual city bylaw officer? Or someone acting under authority of the property owner? Some of the private parking enforcement agencies are somewhat sketchy.
That's ridiculous. I get that the tow truck company will want to be paid for the work, but it should be billed directly to the city since it was their error. Was it an actual city bylaw officer? Or someone acting under authority of the property owner? Some of the private parking enforcement agencies are somewhat sketchy.
Some private property locations have different enforcement protocols: ticket everyone, tow everyone, tow on repeated offence, never tow. Unfortunately, this seems like rotten luck for you. We had a similar situation, where a resident from a condo parked in their designated spot. Unfortunately their vehicle wasn't registered in the private security's parking logs nor did the resident display any parking-permits. Security issued P.O.N. tickets everyday for a week, and also registered incident reports to the property manager. Property manager supposedly reviewed each report and completely ignored it. On day seven, the vehicle was towed. 2 weeks later, the resident returns from vacation to learn his truck was in an impound lot. Ultimately, the property manager had to pay for his tickets/tow/impound fees. Security was advised to never tow from that location, and continue writing tickets everyday. You'll have to find out who made the error here, and make them pay. It may not necessarily be the city by-law officer. 99% of the time, when they issue tickets on private property they take detailed notes because it's basically the complainant/property-manager's word. Especially if the ticket was, "Park without owner's permission".
Some private property locations have different enforcement protocols: ticket everyone, tow everyone, tow on repeated offence, never tow. Unfortunately, this seems like rotten luck for you.
We had a similar situation, where a resident from a condo parked in their designated spot. Unfortunately their vehicle wasn't registered in the private security's parking logs nor did the resident display any parking-permits. Security issued P.O.N. tickets everyday for a week, and also registered incident reports to the property manager. Property manager supposedly reviewed each report and completely ignored it. On day seven, the vehicle was towed. 2 weeks later, the resident returns from vacation to learn his truck was in an impound lot. Ultimately, the property manager had to pay for his tickets/tow/impound fees. Security was advised to never tow from that location, and continue writing tickets everyday.
You'll have to find out who made the error here, and make them pay. It may not necessarily be the city by-law officer. 99% of the time, when they issue tickets on private property they take detailed notes because it's basically the complainant/property-manager's word. Especially if the ticket was, "Park without owner's permission".
Thank you for all your replies. To be clear, the error wasn't made by the bylaw officer (who does work for the city), but by the landlord who had erroneously registered two vehicles in one spot - sorry for the confusion. This was immediately resolved at the scene, at which point the bylaw officer suggested to take it to court to get it dismissed as it was quite clear what happened (he called his supervisor to see if the ticket could be revoked immediately but was told it HAD to be issued to have allowed the tow truck to hook up). It seems like if anyone should compensate the drop fee, it should be the landlord, not the city.
Thank you for all your replies. To be clear, the error wasn't made by the bylaw officer (who does work for the city), but by the landlord who had erroneously registered two vehicles in one spot - sorry for the confusion. This was immediately resolved at the scene, at which point the bylaw officer suggested to take it to court to get it dismissed as it was quite clear what happened (he called his supervisor to see if the ticket could be revoked immediately but was told it HAD to be issued to have allowed the tow truck to hook up).
It seems like if anyone should compensate the drop fee, it should be the landlord, not the city.
File a complaint with the city. No ticket HAS to be issued especially if the ticket issuer doesn't believe an offence has occurred. The manager did this to cover his ass only so that the city didn't have to pay the bill and to leave you on the hook for it (excuse the pun). I'd be filing a complaint against the manager. The dispute is between the city, the tow truck driver and the manager and you should not be involved at all.
File a complaint with the city. No ticket HAS to be issued especially if the ticket issuer doesn't believe an offence has occurred. The manager did this to cover his ass only so that the city didn't have to pay the bill and to leave you on the hook for it (excuse the pun).
I'd be filing a complaint against the manager. The dispute is between the city, the tow truck driver and the manager and you should not be involved at all.
Former Ontario Police Officer. Advice will become less relevant as the time goes by !
File a complaint with the city. No ticket HAS to be issued especially if the ticket issuer doesn't believe an offence has occurred. The manager did this to cover his ass only so that the city didn't have to pay the bill and to leave you on the hook for it (excuse the pun).
I'd be filing a complaint against the manager. The dispute is between the city, the tow truck driver and the manager and you should not be involved at all.
+1
* The above is NOT legal advice. By acting on anything I have said, you assume responsibility for any outcome and consequences. *
http://www.OntarioTicket.com OR http://www.OHTA.ca
pulled over leaving a survey in guelph. After arguing with the officer for about 10 minutes, he mentioned something being wrong with my truck. Told me to put on my emergency brake, and i did. Told me to put it in gear, and i did, truck did not move. Told me to hit the gas, and i did and the truck…
Got two very heavy tickets -- for failing to stop for a school bus, and for using a handheld device. Was running late in a morning rush traffic in Toronto and apparently passed a school bus on the opposite side w/o noticing its signal. A few meters after that I stopped behind the other cars waiting…
I recently received a ticket for proceeding contrary to sign at an intersection. While there are other issues with the offence (sign is not visible until 10ft from intersection, officer wrote wrong license plate number on ticket) my biggest question is about the sign itself.
I posted here a *while* back when I first got my speeding ticket, and I've been fighting it forever. Anyway, long story short - I went and had an appeal and both the prosecutor and the Judge agree that I have valid grounds to appeal on, but what we're arguing is whether the correct remedy is a…
My wife had an auto accident back in May. It is gradually being dealt with by our insurance company ( by the broker actually). My question is about the legal power of the insurance code OAP1. Evidently this set of rules is the Ten Commandments for the insurance companies and the adjustors seem to…
What is the requirement for stopping when a school bus is traveling down the roadway, initiates the flashing red lights while still moving but has not yet stopped? If a motorist is traveling through an intersection (through the free-flow approach, minor-street stop controlled) and an oncoming…
In 2005, the government passed legislation that enabled the introduction of variable speed limits at some point in the future. It didn't take effect right away, so it sat waiting for "proclamation by the Lieutenant Governor." Just by chance... I was reading the HTA earlier while browsing this…
I was on my way to work on a divided four lane highway. I was in the right hand lane following the flow of traffic. There was a slower car ahead of me and I wanted to change lanes and maintain my speed. When I looked in my left side mirror, I notice a red car going pretty fast in the passing…
So i got charged with Hand Held Device, just want to ask everyone if i could use this as my defence
It was midnight, I was dropping my fiance to pick up something on north bound Yonge st (near church) with my emergency lights on, Officer came and asked me to move along so i went up a few streets and…
Refund on towing fee related to dismissed parking ticket
