Passing on the right on a one lane street!

Noahide Laws
Newbie
Newbie
Posts: 4
Joined:

Passing on the right on a one lane street!

Unread post by Noahide Laws »

Hello,

I haven't been able to find a case like this anywhere on the internet so far.
A car was traveling in the left side of a one lane street and went to make a right turn into a plaza. When making the turn he hit a car to the right of him with his right fender hitting car B's driver's side front door. Driver A got out and said you are not allowed to pass on the right and especially this being a one lane street!
Car B claimed that this street is 2 lane because cars always line up in two files up the road at the stop light. Up ahead about 100 meters is a light where a car can turn left or right but cannot go straight.

Who is at fault here? Car A should have been paying attention that no one is going to squeeze in between him and the curb (wide lane where cars can park on the side but no cars were there) Or car B is at fault for trying to pass on the right of a one lane street, cutting off the guy in front and speeding ahead of him thus creating a dangerous situation? Or are both at fault in this case?

Thank you in advance,


argyll
VIP
VIP
Posts: 827
Joined:

Re: Passing on the right on a one lane street!

Unread post by argyll »

If it's two marked lanes then Driver A will be at fault. Regardless of anything else it is the person who changes lane's responsibility to make sure the path is clear.
Former Ontario Police Officer. Advice will become less relevant as the time goes by !




jsherk
High Authority
High Authority
Posts: 1722
Joined:

Re: Passing on the right on a one lane street!

Unread post by jsherk »

Your description of street is very confusing to me. At first I thought you said it was one way, but now you are saying there is a yellow line seperating the directions. So the car traveling in the left lane was on the wrong side of the street?
+++ This is not legal advice, only my opinion +++




bend
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 1073
Joined:

Re: Passing on the right on a one lane street!

Unread post by bend »

jsherk wrote:Your description of street is very confusing to me. At first I thought you said it was one way, but now you are saying there is a yellow line seperating the directions. So the car traveling in the left lane was on the wrong side of the street?
One lane going in each direction, not one way street. He/she is saying the lane is wide enough to fit a second car side by side in the same direction but is not marked as 2 separate lanes.

Image

The lanes are wide because there are stretches where the right side is marked for parking.

That's my understanding.


jsherk
High Authority
High Authority
Posts: 1722
Joined:

Re: Passing on the right on a one lane street!

Unread post by jsherk »

My guess is the yellow vehicle that turned into the green vehicle be at fault as the green vehicle was not passing until the yellow one slowed downed and turned. The green vehicle could argue they were going same speed as yellow and not passing and the yellow vehicle just suddenly slowed down and turned into green.

Just my opinion of course!
+++ This is not legal advice, only my opinion +++




Noahide Laws
Newbie
Newbie
Posts: 4
Joined:

Re: Passing on the right on a one lane street!

Unread post by Noahide Laws »

yes, the diagram is right on!

the green vehicle cut off the yellow vehicle, had no right to squeeze in on the right like that but the yellow still had to check the blind spot. question is since yellow had his right turn signal turned on then isn't the green car at fault?


UnluckyDuck
Member
Member
Posts: 201
Joined:

Re: Passing on the right on a one lane street!

Unread post by UnluckyDuck »

Noahide Laws wrote:yes, the diagram is right on!

the green vehicle cut off the yellow vehicle, had no right to squeeze in on the right like that but the yellow still had to check the blind spot. question is since yellow had his right turn signal turned on then isn't the green car at fault?
Just because a vehicle has it's turn signal on, doesn't mean it has the right of way (except for busses, gotta yield for them). If that's the case, I can cross all lanes of the 401 at 40, and if I hit, I wouldn't be at fault because I had my signal on.

As for this specific situation, because it was a single lane road, legally, the green car could not overtake, let alone overtake on the right. So personally, I would believe the green car is at fault.




jsherk
High Authority
High Authority
Posts: 1722
Joined:

Re: Passing on the right on a one lane street!

Unread post by jsherk »

The only people's opinions that matter on this are:
#1 - The police officers opinion on who to charge.
#2 - The insurance company's opinion on who is at fault.

They are independent decisions of each other, meaning (as an example only) the officer may decide to only charge vehicle B with improper passing, but the insurance company may decide to put 100% fault on vehicle A.
+++ This is not legal advice, only my opinion +++


argyll
VIP
VIP
Posts: 827
Joined:

Re: Passing on the right on a one lane street!

Unread post by argyll »

Sorry. Ignore all my previous comments. I was completely reading this wrong.

Personally I would place blame on vehicle B. Without marked lanes this is a one lane road. I suspect, however, that the insurance company will split the blame.
Former Ontario Police Officer. Advice will become less relevant as the time goes by !


User avatar
Decatur
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 685
Joined:

Re: Passing on the right on a one lane street!

Unread post by Decatur »

I'd actually consider charging both drivers. The green car for a Pass on right-not in safety. HTA 150(1) The yellow car for Turn-not in safety. HTA 142(1)
I won't regurgitate the sections. I figure most of you can navigate the HTA.






Post Reply

Return to “Improper passing”