I have a trial in a few hours. is it possible to use the satellite view from google earth as a way to explain the intersection very well and also to prove that the officer could not have an unobstructed line of sight to traffic lights from where he/she was parked. Plz reply soon
Can a google earth satellite image be used in trial?
- highwaystar
- Sr. Member

- Posts: 380
- Joined: Fri Oct 11, 2013 5:46 pm
-
Posting Awards
Re: Can a google earth satellite image be used in trial?
It all depends on the JP. If they apply correct evidence law than the answer is NO. You would need to bring in the Google employee who took the images to authenticate them, confirm it hasn't been doctored, and whether the location is an accurate reflection of the location at the relevant time. Without proper authentication, the image is prejudicial and should be inadmissible since there is no way to know when it was taken, if the location looked the same way on the date of offence, and whether any modifications have been made (i.e. Google often filters out information from their images such as faces, plates, numbers, etc.).
Bottom line: some JP's allow the images to be used to assist a defendant in testifying but the image itself is not admitted into evidence as an exhibit. In that case, the court is NOT suppose to look at the image themselves (only the witness gets to look at it). However, other JPs blur the law of evidence and will look at the photos themselves, or worse yet, admit them into evidence! It doesn't hurt to try your luck----a wise prosecutor will likely object and set out the law. However, other times, even with objections, the JP allows it in. Just keep in mind that if the images ARE admitted into evidence, there is always the possibility that the prosecution appeals the case due to an error of law. That rarely happens, however, that WOULD give them excellent grounds for an appeal. You need to assess whether its worth the risk.
Re: Can a google earth satellite image be used in trial?
The #1 problem with Google Maps, Earth & Streetview images is that the pictures were taken a long time ago. The intersection you received the offence notice may look different.
Google Earth images can be years old.
I read a decision on CanLII with a driver who received a ticket on the 407ETR for driving by a police vehicle with emergency lights at 105 km/hr. He didn't move over or slow down for the cruiser. Because he took pictures months later, that didn't go too well for him.
R. v. Drljevic, 2010 ONCJ 188 (CanLII) http://canlii.ca/t/29w7t
[48] During the course of his examination in chief, the defendant identified and qualified four photographs of the relevant portion of Highway 407, which he took on July 12th, 2009. Even though these photographs were taken approximately nine months after the time of the alleged offence, the photographs were admitted into evidence as exhibit nos. one to four, on the basis that they would be afforded the appropriate weight given their date.
[57] In making reference to photographic exhibits nos. one and four, the defendant acknowledged that the position of his vehicle in the photographs was just an estimate of the location of the police vehicle stopped at the side of the road at the relevant time. He admitted that he did not take the photographs until approximately nine months after the time of the alleged offence and he acknowledged that his recollection as to the purported location of the police vehicle could have been inaccurate.
It's in your best interest to take the pictures yourself.
Similar Topics
-
-
- Earth Day...
- Posted in General Talk
- By FyreStorm on
- Replies: 3
-
-
-
- 1398 Elgin Ave, Winnipeg, MB, Google Street view.
- Posted in General Talk
- By hwybear on
- Replies: 2
-
-
-
-
- "Bilingual Defence" - Where it can be used
- Posted in Courts and Procedure
- By Radar Identified on
- Replies: 18
-
-
-
- disclosure notes from police/utterances - can they be used?
- Posted in Exceeding the speed limit by 16 to 29 km/h
- By PaulinCanada on
- Replies: 2
-
-
-
- Used vehicle information package Sect. 11.1
- Posted in PART 2: Permits
- By racer on
-
-
-
- General Slang's & Terms Used On www.OHTA.ca
- Posted in Forum Rules
- By Reflections on
-
-
-
- Insurance valid when buying a used car?
- Posted in Compulsory Automobile Insurance Act
- By cruzmisl on
- Replies: 5
-
-
-
- Speeding on off-ramp (warning sign used as speed limit )
- Posted in General Talk
- By md174 on
- Replies: 1
-
-
-
- Was the incorrect sign used? 25 over in a 50.
- Posted in Exceeding the speed limit by 16 to 29 km/h
- By HiGloss on
- Replies: 4
-
-
-
-
I don't know if the cop used a radar or not - what next?
- Posted in General Talk
- By littleredecho on
- Replies: 9
-
-
-
-
-
- Used a file ticket service - received a fine in the mail
- Posted in Courts and Procedure
- By method76 on
- Replies: 3
-
-
-
- Will statement be used in court
- Posted in General Talk
- By 287 on
- Replies: 4
-
-
-
- RIDE checks used to be unlawful
- Posted in General Talk
- By jsherk on
- Replies: 3
-
-
-
- Radar used by officer driving in front
- Posted in Exceeding the speed limit by 30 to 49 km/h
- By 5bs on
- Replies: 5
-
-
-
- Used car seller liability
- Posted in Other Ontario Provincial Acts Related to Traffic
- By zhechaojin on
- Replies: 1
-
-
-
-
Suspected mileage tampering after used car purchase
- Posted in General Talk
- By Creggerj on
- Replies: 1
-
-
-
-
- Can I attend a speeding ticket trial on behalf of someone...
- Posted in Courts and Procedure
- By Susanna on
- Replies: 8
-
-
-
- Speed can Increase at trial - Court of Appeal
- Posted in Courts and Procedure
- By hwybear on
-
Featured Topics
Got Two Tickets on The Spot
I have been reading Fight Your Traffic Ticket site and have a couple of comments.
I was issued two tickets at the same time, one for invalid left turn (Hwy 7 in Markham and Swansea). Another one, because the officer did not like my copy of registration documents.
I am planning to challenge it in the…
36km over on HWY 401
Hi all,
This happened in last year (2015) April. I was going to pick up my son from Queen's University (Kingston) after his exams, and I guess I was too excited and was caught speeding 36km. The cop didn't say anything to me, just asked for my registration etc. Came back and handed me the ticket and…
Hire paralegal or no?
Asking for input on whether I should hire someone or go to court myself.
Situation:
Was on a 60 road with a bit of traffic. Construction on the two right lanes leaving just a left turn lane and the centre lane. It was a green light so I accelerated (also writing down on my statement that I…
72 in a 50 zone
Hi,
I got ticketed for a 72 in a 50 zone that I actually thought was a 60 zone as it was less than a km before.
I had an aggressive driver on my bumper so after tapping my brakes a few time I accelerated to merge into a different lane which was when I got caught in a speed trap.
The combination of…
In Timmins the accident victim gets the ticket too!
I'm laughing my a$$ off at the scales of injustice in this town... This is a crazy story!
I'm cycling from home to work on Oct. 3 & get struck while traveling through my green light by a jeep turning right at his red light at the corner of Hwy101 & Brunette Road (Hollinger Park)!…
Careless driving. Judge said no suspension. But it happened
I was in court last week and the crown and judge agreed on a joint submittion that I plea guilty to dangerious driving. The judge commended me on the work I have done to improve myself and stated that there would be no prohibition on my drivers licence. He gave me a fine and one years probation…
Disobey Official Sign 151(1)
Hi all,
Got a ticket for failure to obey sign. Essentially went straight on a right turn lane when there was a traffic blitz going south from Markham Main st past Hwy 7 east.
I received my notice of trial for July 17th but I assumed this was going to be a first appearance or is this the actual trial…
Breathalyzer Test
Hi everyone!
I've posted at this forum before under a different username a while back, which I unfortunately can't remember, and at that time the people who replied back were extremely helpful and for that I'm grateful.
Last night I was leaving Toronto driving north on University just north of Queens…
Officer said he would cancel ticket..but didn't..Help please
In early March I was driving in the Yonge & Churchil area. An officer said I failed to stop at a stop sign and ticketed me 110+3 demerits. While getting my license etc. I have multiple photocopy of my car ownership in my car, and that I thought I handed him the copy with the validation…
Contesting Fail 2 Surrender Insurance card ticket after paid
Hi, I am from Ontraio, Canada. I was using my friends car for moving some stuff around and was stopped by police and could not produce insurance slip. Got $65 ticket and paid it thinking not to make fuss about it. I know I made a mistake by not contesting it more so given that it was my first…