Page 2 of 4

Re: Section 172 the illegal legislation governing street racing

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 8:55 am
by hwybear
Bookm wrote:If your feelin' confidant.... GET CHARGED!! ;)

Then make it a "good one" (ie 200+)


Re: Section 172 the illegal legislation governing street racing

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 8:56 am
by hwybear

It is actually quite interesting.....despite the 7 day impundment, the vehicle can actually be held until the court date if an arrest was made!


Re: Section 172 the illegal legislation governing street racing

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 11:46 am
by racer
Proper1 wrote:
Bookm wrote:If your feelin' confident.... GET CHARGED!! ;)

That would be an impressive way to demonstrate your conviction (in more ways than one), but unnecessary. You're a citizen of Canada, the law applies to you, the law is an assault on you, and there's no other effective way to challenge it. Kvetching in an online forum, even as admirable a one as this, is never going to be an effective challenge to an unjust law. Wikipedia has a clear and concise article on this at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadian_c ... tional_law

There are many ways of promoting social justice. One is filing constitutional challenges. Another is going to jail for your convictions. The simplest is having your voice heard by the community, which is what we are trying to accomplish with this forum. If the law is unjust, and you feel it, we have no problem supporting online and mail-in petitions. Bel has one against 172, for example. Click it through, register your vote!


Re: Section 172 the illegal legislation governing street racing

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 1:08 pm
by hwybear
racer wrote: . If the law is unjust, and you feel it, we have no problem supporting online and mail-in petitions. Bel has one against 172, for example. Click it through, register your vote!

Forgot about the petition.....coles notes what is it about?


Re: Section 172 the illegal legislation governing street racing

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 1:34 pm
by hwybear

and the stats thing keeps being brought up....can be construed however the person looking at it want it to be....

Canada Election 2008

38% Conservatives

27% Liberals

18% NDP

10% Bloc

6% Green

1% other

So Liberals/NDP/Bloc state.....wait here...55% wants us to be the government as we have a majority. :shock:


Re: Section 172 the illegal legislation governing street racing

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 5:00 pm
by Radar Identified

Coles notes on petition:

Revise section 172 so that no up-front penalties are imposed on motorist at roadside. (No 7-day vehicle impoundment, no license suspension.) After-conviction penalties to remain unchanged. At least that's what it was when I signed it a while ago.

hwybear wrote:and the stats thing keeps being brought up

Referring to the reduction in fatalities or the conviction rates under 172 or...?

hwybear wrote:So Liberals/NDP/Bloc state.....wait here...55% wants us to be the government as we have a majority.

Don't get me started on that one. :x


Re: Section 172 the illegal legislation governing street racing

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 5:59 pm
by hwybear
Radar Identified wrote:Coles notes on petition:

Revise section 172 so that no up-front penalties are imposed on motorist at roadside. (No 7-day vehicle impoundment, no license suspension.) After-conviction penalties to remain unchanged. At least that's what it was when I signed it a while ago.

thank you....I personally can not support the petition with both the items involved in there. A modified version I would be able to and probably a lot more support from others as well.


Re: Section 172 the illegal legislation governing street racing

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 6:11 pm
by Reflections
thank you....I personally can not support the petition with both the items involved in there. A modified version I would be able to and probably a lot more support from others as well.

Modify it so that a person does not lose their ability to goto work for a week. I know that the local officers don't go out and look to lay this charge but if it is laid incorrectly, for any reason. Song lyric goes here......."Wrong, can't be undone...." Kenny Wayne Sheppard. I think thats how you spell it.....


Re: Section 172 the illegal legislation governing street racing

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 9:18 pm
by Radar Identified
hwybear wrote:thank you....I personally can not support the petition with both the items involved in there.

We'll probably have to agree to disagree on how far to go with amending s. 172. Hypothetically, would you consider signing it if it was to remove the vehicle impoundment?

Reflections wrote:if it is laid incorrectly, for any reason. Song lyric goes here......."Wrong, can't be undone...."

Exactly. :evil:


Re: Section 172 the illegal legislation governing street racing

Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 11:40 pm
by cruzmisl

Just stay below 49km/h over the limit and you'll get to work just fine.

I like 172. Finally some legislation with some teeth. Thats just my opinion though.


Re: Section 172 the illegal legislation governing street racing

Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 2:26 am
by Reflections
Just stay below 49km/h over the limit and you'll get to work just fine.

Thats not the only thing that'll get yer car towed.....too many loose definitions :x


Re: Section 172 the illegal legislation governing street racing

Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 4:03 am
by admin
Proper1 wrote:
Bookm wrote:If your feelin' confident.... GET CHARGED!! ;)

Kvetching in an online forum, even as admirable a one as this,

Hey Proper1, thanks for the comment for the site, but hey I have to say the word "Kvetching" is a new word to me. I actually googled it for its definition lol. Thanks, I just learned a new word today!


Re: Section 172 the illegal legislation governing street racing

Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 8:54 am
by hwybear
Radar Identified wrote: Hypothetically, would you consider signing it if it was to remove the vehicle impoundment?

Exactly, then it would be "on-line" with the 90 day suspension (ie charged with offence, loss of licence)


Re: Section 172 the illegal legislation governing street racing

Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 8:59 am
by hwybear
Reflections wrote:

Modify it so that a person does not lose their ability to goto work for a week. .....

Does not prevent them from going to work...use their legs, bicycle, carpool, bus....it's also better for the environment :)


Re: Section 172 the illegal legislation governing street racing

Posted: Thu Jan 15, 2009 9:59 am
by BelSlySTi
Reflections wrote:
Just stay below 49km/h over the limit and you'll get to work just fine.

Thats not the only thing that'll get yer car towed.....too many loose definitions :x

Insert sarcasim................It certainly is, why else would they call it the Street Racing Law?